MCMormons Are Not Christians
Menu

core argument

The Trinity is a biblical conclusion

The word Trinity is later than the Bible. The doctrine is the church's way of refusing to drop any of the Bible's claims: there is one God, the Son is God, the Spirit is God, and Father, Son, and Spirit are personally distinct.

No. 01

Scripture starts with one God#

The Christian doctrine of the Trinity begins where Israel's confession begins: there is one God. Deuteronomy 6 confesses one Lord, Isaiah denies any other God before, after, beside, or unknown to the Lord, and Paul can speak of many so-called gods while still confessing one God and one Lord.

That means the Trinity is not a move away from monotheism. It is an argument about who belongs inside the identity of the one God. Any Christian account of Father, Son, and Spirit has to preserve that boundary.

No. 02

The Son is named as God and Creator#

John says the Word was with God, was God, and made all things. Thomas confesses the risen Jesus as Lord and God. Colossians says all things in heaven and on earth were created by Him and for Him, and Hebrews places the Son above angels with divine honor and throne language.

Those texts do not merely say Jesus is authorized by God or unusually close to God. They place the Son on the Creator side of the Creator-creature line. Christianity confesses the Son as true God because the New Testament gives Him divine identity, work, honor, and name.

No. 03

The Spirit is treated as divine#

Acts 5 treats lying to the Holy Spirit as lying to God. Paul blesses the church with the grace of the Lord Jesus Christ, the love of God, and the fellowship of the Holy Spirit. Ephesians grounds the church's unity in one Spirit, one Lord, and one God and Father.

The Spirit is not handled as an impersonal religious feeling or merely a delegated force. He speaks, gives fellowship, is lied to, and belongs with Father and Son in the church's worship and life before God.

No. 04

Father, Son, and Spirit are distinct#

The Bible also distinguishes Father, Son, and Spirit. The Son prays to the Father, is sent by the Father, and speaks of the Spirit as another Helper. The Father is not the Son, the Son is not the Spirit, and the Spirit is not the Father.

That distinction matters because the Trinity is not a word for one person wearing three masks. Christianity is trying to hold together the whole pattern: one God, the Son as God, the Spirit as God, and real personal distinction.

No. 05

Matthew 28 gives one baptismal name#

The Great Commission sends the church to baptize into the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit. The text does not give three unrelated divine names or one superior name with two lesser appendages. Father, Son, and Spirit stand together in the one baptismal name.

Matthew 28 is not the only Trinity text, and it does not answer every later technical question by itself. But it shows that Christian initiation from the beginning was triadic without becoming tritheistic. The one name matters.

No. 06

Distinction is not modalism#

Some objections to the Trinity only disprove modalism. When Jesus is baptized, prays, or speaks to the Father, those texts show that Father and Son are not the same person. Trinitarian Christianity agrees.

The disputed move is different: distinct persons do not become separate divine beings. LDS doctrine defines the Godhead as three separate beings united in purpose, while Christianity confesses Father, Son, and Holy Spirit as distinct persons who are the one God.

No. 07

Later word, earlier doctrine#

The word Trinity is later, but later wording can faithfully summarize earlier doctrine. Christians needed precise language because Scripture forced several claims to be confessed at once: one God, the Son as God and Creator, the Spirit as divine, and real distinction among Father, Son, and Spirit.

Nicaea did not invent the deity of Christ out of thin air. It guarded the biblical line that the Son is begotten, not made, true God from true God. Rejecting that answer is not merely rejecting a fourth-century label; it changes the doctrine those words were protecting.

No. 08

Notes for different readers#

For Latter-day Saints, the key issue is not whether Father, Son, and Holy Ghost are distinct. Christianity already teaches distinction. The issue is whether they are separate divine beings united in purpose or distinct persons who are the one God. Official LDS sources take the first path.

For Jehovah's Witness readers, the pressure point is the Son's identity as Creator and God. For Muslim readers, the first clarification is that the Trinity is not three gods or a divine family. For Jewish readers, the disagreement begins with whether the New Testament rightly identifies Jesus and the Spirit within the one God of Israel. Those are different objections, but they meet the same biblical claims.

References

The argument rests on public Scripture, official LDS material, and Christian sources.

  1. BibleRef

    Christian monotheism inherits Israel's confession, not a council of true gods.

  2. BibleRef

    This directly challenges exalted humans becoming gods in the same order.

  3. BibleRef

    This contrasts with Abraham 4's language of 'the Gods' organizing creation.

  4. BibleRef

    This reinforces monotheism as more than one preferred object of worship.

  5. BibleRef

    Paul answers divine plurality by folding Jesus into Christian monotheism, not by adding a second God.

  6. John 1

    Bible

    BibleRef

    If all created things came through Christ, Christ is not inside the created order.

  7. John 20

    Bible

    BibleRef

    The confession belongs inside Jewish monotheism, not a category of lesser gods.

  8. BibleRef

    The Son is before all created things, not one spirit child among others.

  9. BibleRef

    This separates Christ from angelic or spirit-child categories.

  10. BibleRef

    Triadic language belongs with one divine name, not three unrelated beings.

  11. Acts 5

    Bible

    BibleRef

    The Spirit is treated as divine, not merely an impersonal influence.

  12. BibleRef

    Father, Son, and Spirit belong together in Christian worship and blessing.

  13. BibleRef

    The triadic pattern is tied to one divine foundation, not a council of separate gods.

  14. John 17

    Bible

    BibleRef

    The text supports unity language, but it must be read with John's claims that the Word is God and Creator.

  15. The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints

    Official LDS teaching that the Father, Son, and Holy Ghost are distinct beings, one in purpose and doctrine.

  16. The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints

    Official LDS article saying Latter-day Saints do not believe in the traditional Trinity and instead teach three separate beings united in purpose.

  17. The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints

    Official LDS source teaching that the Holy Ghost is the third member of the Godhead and a personage of spirit.

  18. The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints

    General Conference address openly rejecting the doctrine of three persons in one substance.

  19. The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints

    Official essay acknowledging LDS rejection of post-New Testament creeds and distinct restoration claims.

  20. Nicene Creed

    Christian

    United States Conference of Catholic Bishops

    Representative text of the historic Nicene confession of one God, the Trinity, and the eternal deity of Christ.